How Long Can Brownie Batter Sit Out? Top 50 Best Answers

Is it okay to refrigerate flourless chocolate brownie batter for a few hours before cooking? I’m having an Easter party and would like to serve them fresh instead of keeping them warm in the oven as they have dried in the past. I won’t have time to mix the batter once the party starts, and we won’t eat for a couple of hours.

Our answer

Nigella’s Flourless Chocolate Brownies in Hot Chocolate Sauce (by NIGELLA EXPRESS) are made with ground almonds (almond flour) instead of wheat flour. The almonds help keep the brownies moist, but as with all brownies, they will lose their squidgy if over-baked. Since Bownie batter doesn’t contain any leavening agents like baking powder, it should be possible to make the batter a little ahead of time. However, we’re a little cautious about chilling the batter since it contains butter and melted chocolate, and both ingredients will set when chilled. This could mean the middle of the brownie is undercooked and still cold.

Instead, you could prepare the dough ahead of time and leave it in a cool place before baking. Because the recipe includes eggs, you can prepare the batter up to 2 hours before baking, but no longer. The sauce can be made up to a week in advance and refrigerated. To reheat the sauce, place in a heatproof bowl over a saucepan of hot water until warmed through, stirring occasionally.

Everyone loves easy cake recipes. The best part? Whether it’s cake mix or scratch cake batter, you can store your batter in the fridge for up to 2 days!

A lot of people love to bake their own cakes from scratch because they know what ingredients are going to be mixed into it. It’s not like buying a cake with artificial ingredients or preservatives.

It’s best to stick to the recipe and bake your freshly made dough right away, but when life gets in your way, sometimes you can’t always do what needs to be done.

So no worries! In most cases, you can save cake batter (or leftover cake batter) and bake later.

The best part is that many cake batters are fairly forgiving of storage.

These include oil-based cake batters (e.g. carrot, red velvet), muffin batter, cupcake batter, quick bread batter, etc. Their texture will even improve a bit with resting.

You can keep them for days and even weeks and months without losing flavor or quality.

Sponge cakes are almost always damaged by a long rest period as they are made with egg foam to rise.

In short, it all depends on the ingredients of the dough: the basic dough stores better than something more complicated.

Can you refrigerate cake batter?

Yes, the cake batter can be refrigerated overnight or up to 48 hours to preserve freshness and ability to rise.

Still, it would be best if you remember that refrigerating the cake batter doesn’t stop it from losing its rising ability.

The whipped air slowly escapes, eventually resulting in a shorter and denser cake.

The leavening agents (baking powder and baking soda) will also eventually become ineffective and affect the cake rise.

So for best results try to chill the cake batter for a few hours or at least overnight.

How long does cake batter keep?

You shouldn’t leave your dough at room temperature for more than an hour.

The dough can be kept for a maximum of three months. You can keep it in the fridge for up to 2 days and freeze it for three months.

The longer you keep it refrigerated or frozen, the less chance your cake will rise properly. Mainly if your dough has baking powder and no baking powder in it.

Interestingly, scratch cake batter is more affected by refrigeration and freezing than cake mix batter.

It is best to bake the cake batter immediately after mixing. Or refrigerate for a few hours, overnight at most, and bake the next day.

Save cake batter

There are three ways you can store the cake batter: at room temperature, in the fridge, or by freezing.

How long cake batter can be stored at room temperature depends on the type of batter, the leavening agents used, and the room temperature.

As a rule of thumb, your dough can’t stay at room temperature for more than an hour.

It applies to all cake batters, especially those containing raw eggs, milk, buttermilk, or other dairy products.

If you need to store the dough for more than an hour, consider storing it in the refrigerator.

Another question is how long the cake batter will retain its rising ability. The longer it is at room temperature, the more it loses this property.

First the dough loses the beaten air; then the chemical leaven reduces its activity.

So it makes sense to refrigerate the dough if you don’t want to bake it right away.

You’re probably wondering if the cake batter can be frozen. Yes, you can freeze most cake batters for up to three months.

But if the batter has risen with whipped egg whites, like chiffon or angel cakes, the freezing process will ruin the batter.

Read the instructions on how to freeze cake batter.

How to chill cake batter

The best way to chill the cake batter is to follow these simple steps:

Leave your batter in a mixing bowl or transfer to an airtight container. If you leave it in the mixing bowl, cover the dough with cling film. It prevents drying out. Place the cake batter in the refrigerator for up to 48 hours.

And don’t forget to write down the time you put your bowl or airtight container in the fridge.

Choose the best quality PE food packaging from the two types of food packaging, PVC (polyvinyl chloride) and PE (polyethylene). This is what food safety experts recommend.

You can also use a zip-top bag or food-safe container (BPA-free plastic or glass).

How to bake cold dough

When ready to bake, take the chilled dough out of the fridge, let it come to room temperature for about 30 minutes, and then bake.

Or you can bake your dough straight from the fridge by adding a few minutes to the baking time.

If the dough was frozen, let it thaw in the refrigerator overnight. If using a ziplock bag, cut off a corner of the bag and press the batter into the prepared cake pans; then bake.

Or you fill the batter in a sealable piping bag and fill muffin tins with it.

If you frozen your batter in a baking pan or cupcake tin, thaw and bake. Or bake from frozen and add extra baking minutes.

Then use your creative ways to decorate the cake or cupcakes with whipped cream and fresh fruit.

Conclusion

The best way to ensure a perfect cake every time is to bake the cake batter right after mixing.

However, you can store your dough at room temperature for an hour or refrigerate for up to 48 hours.

I hope this article helps you understand all the information you need to know about storing the cake batters.

frequently asked Questions

This post contains affiliate links.

Baking a fresh batch of brownies is one of my favorite things to do in my kitchen. However, baking brownies properly is an important skill that every baker needs to learn. From my many years of baking experience I have learned that things don’t always go according to plan in the kitchen.

There was one instance where I found I didn’t have enough time to finish baking my brownies while I was in the middle of making the brownie batter. This brought up a few questions I needed to know the answers to. Can I Freeze Brownie Batter? How do I properly freeze my unbaked brownie mix?

Brownie batter can be frozen without compromising its integrity. Place the unbaked brownie mixture in a freezer bag and place on a flat baking sheet. This allows the dough to freeze flat and spread well. Alternatively, place the batter in a disposable pan and wrap in foil to prevent freezer burn.

During my baking journey, I’ve baked hundreds of brownies for all kinds of occasions. Learning how to preserve the integrity of my unbaked brownie mix has saved me a lot of time over the years. Because of that, I have a few more tips for you to help you freeze your brownie batter properly.

How to freeze brownie batter

If you want to freeze your brownie batter for a short time, consider using the freezer bag option. Place your finished brownie batter in a freezer bag and spread it down the length of the bag. This keeps the dough nice and flat during the freezing process.

When you’re done, be sure to remove any excess air from the bag and seal it! Completely removing the air from the freezer bag can help prevent the brownie batter from oxidizing. Oxidation can spoil any food faster, even if it’s frozen.

*Completely remove any air and seal the freezer bag and also help prevent your brownie batter from getting freezer burn*

*By the way, to save even more time I found this awesome brownie pan that will pre-cut your brownies! The non-stick brownie baking pan with dividers saves my time AND keeps my brownies from breaking! You can find them on Amazon!

Place freezer bag full of brownie batter in a shallow sheet pan/cookie tin to keep the batter flat. I also like to place a paper towel between the sheet pan and the freezer paper to absorb any excess moisture that might build up.

While it’s less than optimal, another way to short-term freeze your brownie batter is to transfer the batter to a disposable pan and cover it with either aluminum foil or freezer paper. This also prevents the dough from getting freezer burn.

*By the way, if you want to know the true difference between foil, parchment paper, wax paper, and freezer paper, I wrote an in-depth article that breaks down the similarities and differences of each paper, which you can check out here!

How long can you freeze brownie batter?

On average, brownie batter can be frozen for 12 to 18 months without affecting its freshness. Place the unbaked brownie mixture in a freezer bag and remove excess air from the bag. This prevents the brownie batter from oxidizing in the long term and keeps it edible.

As you may already know, air is the enemy of all food. Air oxidizes enzymes in food, leading to food spoilage. Keeping the freezer bag filled with batter airtight is the most important step in keeping it fresher for longer.

Does freezing ruin brownies?

In general, brownie batter can be frozen in the freezer without affecting its freshness. Place the unbaked brownie mixture in a freezer bag and remove excess air from the bag. Place the freezer bag on a flat tray. This allows the dough to freeze flat and spread well.

Regular brownie batter consists of several essential ingredients:

flour

eggs

cocoa powder

sugar

oil or butter

These essential ingredients tend to freeze well and retain their freshness over time while frozen.

How do you thaw frozen brownie batter?

Remove the frozen brownie batter from the freezer and place in the refrigerator. Let it thaw for several hours or overnight. Place the dough on the countertop for 20 minutes or until it comes to room temperature while you preheat the oven. This gradual increase in temperature keeps the dough fresh for baking.

Once you’ve placed the freezer bag of frozen brownie batter in the fridge, I would suggest surrounding the batter with more paper towels. Because the frozen dough will thaw in the refrigerator for several hours, the paper towels will help absorb excess water, which will melt over time.

Also place a paper towel under the freezer bag

This keeps your brownie batter fresh and your fridge nice and clean.

How long can brownie batter be refrigerated?

As a general rule, homemade brownie batter should last 7 days in the refrigerator without sacrificing freshness. Place the unbaked brownie mixture in a freezer bag and remove excess air from the bag. This will help prevent the dough from oxidizing in the long term and make it safe to eat.

If you are ready to bake your dough the next day, refrigerating the dough is the best option for you. It brings out the cocoa flavor in your brownie batter much better than leaving the batter in your pantry.

*By the way, I recently stumbled across the perfect brownie pan that slices the brownies into chunks with no fuss! This Professional Slice Solutions Metallic Brownie Pan measures 9″ x 13″ and will help you get your brownies out of the pan a lot easier! You can check out this brownie pan on Amazon!

While refrigerating your brownie batter for more than a few days can help preserve its freshness, I would suggest freezing your batter instead! Freezing the dough for more than a few days can help the dough retain its freshness longer.

By the way, I recently found this brownie recipe that turned out to be really good. Check it out below:

*Side note: I recently wrote an article on how to remove brownies from the pan without breaking them. This article explains step by step how to safely remove brownies from the pan. You can read this article here!

Summarize…

Knowing that freezing the unbaked brownie mix would not affect the freshness of the brownies, I was able to freeze large batches of brownie batter a few days before baking. Having frozen brownie batter ready to bake gave me the confidence I needed to make the brownies on time during an event!

I know, I know. Waiting for your brownies to cool can be the longest wait of your life. Float in the air in this rich chocolate flavor and stare at the thin, perfectly cracked film on your brownie teasing you with its warmth. I mean it’s basically asking for it.

Asking to be immediately cut and melt in your mouth, that is. But no! Resist temptation at all costs because the perfect brownie is one that has been chilled. You should let your brownies cool for at least 30 minutes before slicing them.

I’m Angie and I’m slightly obsessed with brownies. I started a home baking business last year and my brownies have always been customer favorites. I know exactly how it feels to want to cut brownies as soon as they come out of the oven, and I’ve learned through my mistakes to know exactly why I shouldn’t!

In this article, I share with you the art of chilling brownies. Why we have to, how long we should chill it and how to do it quickly.

I think I deserve pluses for that.

Why cool brownies?

A cruel act like this needs a good justification. Why do we have to wait for brownies to cool down?

The main reason for this is – to achieve a gooey and fiddly consistency, we as bakers are told never to cook a brownie all the way through. To be sure, we take them out when they’re still a little short, especially in the middle.

The residual heat from the brownie pan cooks the brownie a little more, so you don’t have to worry about your brownies being undercooked.

But since the inside of the brownie isn’t fully set yet, removing it from the pan and slicing it through will cause the brownie to fall apart and all that’s left is a gooey mess and chocolate all over it. To achieve the clean cuts you see on store-bought brownies, you need to let them cool.

Aside from the fact that chilled and firm brownies are easier to cut, many say brownies taste even better the next day because the chilling process helps them lock in all the flavors better.

How long to cool brownies?

How long is this waiting time? Expect at least 30 minutes and we’ll get started from there.

For a clean cut

You need to let your brownies cool for at least half an hour before removing them from the pan. The length of time may vary depending on the temperature in your location. Rule of thumb – wait until your brownie is completely cool to the touch before slicing it.

To get a perfectly clean edge, use a knife warmed in hot water and wipe off any residue on the knife before and after each cut.

For frosting

If you plan to top your brownies with a layer of frosting, make sure your brownies are completely cool, preferably in the fridge, before you start frosting.

This isn’t a strict rule if you plan to cover your brownie in ganache, but expect your ganache to take longer than usual to set.

If using buttercream icing, the heat of the brownie will cause your buttercream to melt or crack, which is why a chilled or fully chilled brownie is preferred.

How to quickly chill brownies?

If the 30+ minute wait is just too much for you, try this method to cool it down faster.

To do this, you’ll need aluminum foil, ice, a bowl, tray, or sink large enough to fit on top of your brownie tray.

Wrap the entire tray of brownies in foil. Double the layer for extra security. This is to prevent water from coming into contact with your brownies. We don’t want mushy brownies. Fill your bowl, tray or sink with ice. Place your foil wrapped tray inside and cover the sides with ice as well. You can also use ice packs for this. Take out your tray after 20-30 minutes.

This method should greatly reduce the time it takes for your brownie to cool completely.

frequently asked Questions

Still have questions about chilling brownies? Here I answer them for you.

Will my brownies harden as they cool?

Your brownies will firm up as they cool, but not hard unless you’ve chilled them in the fridge or freezer.

The texture of your brownies should be at their best at room temperature – soft, firm and melt-in-your-mouth. However, the low temperature in the fridge will solidify the butter and chocolate in your brownie and harden it.

Can you let brownies cool overnight?

You can let your brownies cool overnight. In fact, your brownies will taste even better the next day when all the flavors are locked in. Just make sure you wrap them tightly or put them in airtight containers before storing them in the fridge, as the fridge tends to dry out food.

Do you let brownies cool in the pan?

I highly recommend that you cool your brownies in the pan for the first 30 minutes. Any attempt to remove or cut into the pan before it has cooled could result in your brownie falling apart.

Can I put brownies in the freezer?

Yes you can. In fact, freezing brownies is the best way to keep them fresh for a long time. You can freeze brownies for up to 3 months. Just make sure you wrap them airtight in a freezer-safe bag and let them cool completely before putting them in the freezer.

Final Thoughts

Like I said, slicing into freshly baked brownies is a crime you’ll regret (or will you?)

I hope all of this newfound knowledge of chilling brownies has helped you gather enough strength and determination to resist the temptation to eat your brownies as soon as they’re done. Patience is always the key.

Guilty of cutting and eating your brownies right away? Do you think it’s worth it? Let us know what you think in the comments below!

How to Make Glossy Thin Crust Brownies

Method 1: Add sugar to hot butter

There is one important caveat to understand about this method: sugar only dissolves in water. Not fat. In fact, you can dissolve a lot of sugar in water—twice the weight of sugar in any amount of water, as suggested by Dr. Pia Sorensen discussed in Adam Ragusa’s video examining the formation of brownie skin. If you’ve ever made simple syrup, you know how sugar can completely dissolve in water. The same effect does not occur if you heat oil and add sugar.

About twenty percent of butter consists of water. If that water content is hot from the butter melting when you add the sugar, it will dissolve in the water more easily. This helps create that glossy crust, not just on brownies, but on chocolate chip cookies and even chocolate chip cookies with melted butter. I always put the sugar in the hot butter. Look what happens if you don’t:

Note that chilled butter brownies are flatter. They also had a silkier and stickier texture without that chewy bite. The texture just falls flat, which is why I always add the sugar to the hot butter when baking brownies!

The hot butter brownies had a significantly shinier top crust as well as improved texture!

It has the added benefit of chilling the butter faster, so you can add your eggs sooner without scrambling them.

Method 2: Beat eggs + sugar

I first experimented with this technique of beating the sugar into the eggs in 2012. It helps move the sugar so that it better dissolves in the water content of the egg white and sugar and egg proteins form bonds.

I originally learned about it from ScientificallySweet.com, but this meringue technique can actually be traced back to 1929, as described by Stella Parks in her recipe book, BraveTart: Iconic American Desserts, when she discussed how Swans Down swept the brownie game through the publication changed a brownie recipe in a mail-order cookbook in which the “instructions called for whipping the eggs with sugar and melting the butter and chocolate into a kind of ganache. This made brownies more fiddly than cakey…”

The goal is to aerate the eggs and sugar enough to create a foam. The intensity and structure of this foam gives different results:

In my Ultimate Fudgy Brownie recipe, I call for beating the eggs and sugar for 3 minutes. This creates a kind of meringue-cracker crust on top.

In my Brown Butter Brownies (pictured above), heavily inspired by Stella Parks, I ask for the eggs and sugar to be beaten until fully and fully foamed, which takes about 8 minutes. The time actually depends entirely on your mixer power.

In my Best Easy Brownie Recipe, I shorten this frothing technique by hand whisking the eggs, sugar, and butter for 1 minute. However, this happens after the sugar has been added to the mixture of hot butter and melted chocolate. The heat promotes the dissolution of the sugar into the water content.

Method 3: Use powdered sugar instead

Brownies made with powdered sugar have a shinier and more defined thin top crust. They’re also just a little more cakey in texture.

Powdered sugar is finely ground and dissolves much more quickly and easily in the water content of the dough.

Swap powdered sugar for granulated sugar using the following conversion:

1 cup granulated sugar = 1 ½ cups plus 2 tablespoons powdered sugar

Or, better yet, use a kitchen scale and just measure the same weight of total sugar.

Important sugar aspect: Your recipe needs to have ENOUGH sugar to develop a paper-thin crust. The sugar creates the viscosity needed to develop this crust. Balanced brownie recipes have enough sugar to be fudge and moist with the crust on top without becoming cloyingly sweet.

How MOISTURE affects brownies in crazy ways!

When it comes to dissolving sugar in brownie batter, it helps to note that egg whites contain a small amount of water. There is no real water content in melted chocolate. So basically there aren’t many places for the sugar to dissolve in a low moisture recipe like brownies! That’s good, because as you’ll read below, too much water kills that shiny crust.

I know this seems counterintuitive as we need some water content for the sugar to dissolve in, but too much creates a looser consistency (instead of the thicker viscosity we need). This will keep the surface of the brownies from drying out so much that this “skin” forms.

That’s why I’m going to use whole eggs + yolks in my recipes. Too much egg white adds too much water, resulting in brownies that have lots of holes on top instead of a nice crust.

It’s also why my recipe for browned butter brownies has such a great crust—the 20% water content of the butter has evaporated as it browned. The same goes for my Chewy Brownie recipe, which uses part butter and part oil. Oil does not contain water.

The moisture conundrum is also why using brown sugar in a brownie recipe can negatively affect that shiny skin.

If you live in a very humid climate, reaching the brownie crust can be extremely difficult. Just as it’s difficult to make meringue-based desserts in humid climates, the humidity keeps the top of the brownie batter from drying out enough to form that skin.

Method 4: Use chocolate chips

Most brownie recipes that make that crispy crust involve solid chocolate in one form or another. Either melt chocolate into your batter and/or add chocolate chips.

One thought is that the melted chocolate has more fat and less moisture than butter. So if a lot of the fat in the recipe comes from chocolate, there’s less water to keep that crust from forming.

My best Chewy brownie recipe contradicts this, as it’s made only with cocoa powder and almost always results in a glossy crust. So I decided to do some tests.

What I discovered was that the chocolate chips can be a major contributor to the development of this brownie skin. When I’ve made the same brownie recipes with and without chocolate chips, the chips enhance the glossy crust on brownies:

Not only do the chocolate chips help improve that top crust, but they also improve the thickness of the brownies. The difference in texture otherwise only comes from the bites of chocolate chips.

I’m not 100% sure why, but I have two thoughts on this. One is that soy lecithin and milk solids in chocolate chips help develop this crust. It could also be that chocolate chips already have dissolved sugar in them, and that helps the crust develop.

To add chocolate chips to brownies:

For an 8″ x 8″ pan of brownies, add about ¾ cup (128 g) chocolate chips. For a 9″ x 13″ pan of brownies, add 1 ½ cups (256 grams) of chocolate chips. As the last ingredient, carefully fold the chips into the brownie batter.

Who doesn’t love having a delicious load of chocolatey goodness? Brownies are one of our favorite desserts. If you feel the same way, then why not learn how to make them? Here are some common mistakes people make when making brownies.

Are you trying to make brownies and the results are far from exquisite? Do they form a melting, gooey mess? Then something might go wrong somewhere in the process. Personally, I hate when I dream of the perfect brownie and what I get fails quality control somewhere. There must be a streamlined process to make them, right?

If you’re looking for something decadent with a very rich flavor to be your go-to companion when you need some comfort, then check out the following common mistakes and check for yourself before you ruin your load!

You may already know that there are two types of brownie recipes: those that look more like cake and the fudgier variety. How do you distinguish one from the other? Check out the ingredients. If the emphasis is on chocolate and butter, rather than dry ingredients, then you’ve found a fudge-like recipe. But if you’re supposed to be creaming the butter and sugar together, your brownie will most likely come out cake side.

And if you’re looking for some brownie-inspired inspiration, you’ve come to the right place. From Snickers brownies to peanut butter mug brownies to vegan brownies, there are so many delicious treats you can make!

Common mistakes when baking brownies

1. They don’t use the good chocolate

The tastiest treats are usually made from the finest ingredients. So, if you can afford it, don’t just buy plain baking chocolate. Treat yourself to some good chocolate. Also, don’t work with tiny slivers of chocolate as they contain stabilizers that tend to melt poorly. It’s far better to take a large bar of chocolate and cut it into chunks, which will melt more slowly and give much creamier results.

And if you like to mix things up, don’t just go for dark chocolate, even if it’s healthier. Add some of your more sinful flavors, something with a little sugar.

2. Your chocolate is too hot

One of the main things that can go wrong when baking brownies is cooking your eggs. How can this happen? Well, eggs tend to cook pretty quickly when it comes to hot temperatures. And adding your chocolate to eggs when it’s super hot will end up cooking your eggs. This is definitely not the result you are looking for. Allow the chocolate you just melted to cool slightly.

3. Your eggs and butter are too cold

The other temperature-related mistake is using butter and eggs straight from the fridge. Please do not. Make sure you let these come to room temperature before using them in the batter. If you do that, you stand a better chance of getting a smoother batter for the brownies of your dreams.

4. You add too many flavors

Don’t overload your palate with eccentric flavor combinations that contain too many elements. Simply select an additional flavor and ride the chocolate wave. Let the chocolate be the star of the brownie, don’t overshadow it with too many other things. Some ideas what to add: nuts, peanut butter, or cream cheese. And then enjoy the rich flavor you get!

5. They don’t bake enough

What is the key to getting the worst result when baking brownies? Patience is missing! Uncooked brownies are probably the worst because they all melt and have a gross texture. Follow your recipe to the letter, including – or most importantly – the baking time. That way, you’re sure to get some crunch on the crust of your brownie tray.

6. You won’t let her rest

This is another instance where lack of patience will come and bite you in the brownie shell. Once you have cooked your tray for the time required by the recipe, remove it from the oven. But don’t give in to your desire just yet. The brownies are still putting in there and they need time to be the best they can be. Not to mention that they are easier to remove from the tray itself!

Got an old box of brownie mix and want to know if it’s safe to use? That’s a good question that we will answer in this article.

Knowing how to tell if your brownie mix has gone bad is important to avoid consuming spoiled brownies. And you’ll learn an easy way to tell if your brownie mix is ​​good or not.

Whether you’ve found an old box with no expiration date in the back of the pantry or want to know if it’s safe to make brownie mix past the expiration date, we’ve got you covered.

We will also cover the difference between the best before date and the expiry date. Note: they are not the same. We’ll even give you tips on the best way to store the brownie mix to maximize its shelf life.

Can you use expired brownie mix?

First, let’s discuss the date on your brownie mix box. This date is almost always a best before date and not an expiry date. Big difference!

A best before date is the manufacturer’s recommended date for the highest flavor and texture of your prepared brownies. On the other hand, an expiration date would mean that the brownie mix is ​​no longer safe to consume. And that doesn’t mean the date on your box of brownie mix.

The vast majority of brownie mixes don’t actually expire. The ingredients are usually safe to eat many months past the date on the package.

The main problem you’ll run into when using an old box of brownie mix is ​​that the leavening agents may have lost their potency as well as some impact on flavor. But that doesn’t mean your brownies aren’t safe to eat.

Most brownie mixes contain flour, baking powder or baking soda (your leavening agent), salt, sugar, and cocoa or other flavoring.

These types of ingredients have a long shelf life when stored in a cool, dark place. As mentioned above, a very old brownie mix may not rise or offer as robust a flavor as a fresh box of brownie mix.

Can you use expired brownie mix?

Yes! Since the date on the box is a best before date and not an expiration date, it’s perfectly safe to consume brownies made from a mix that is months past the best before date.

Keep in mind that the brownie mix should not be exposed to moisture or extreme heat as this can cause certain ingredients in the mix to spoil.

In fact, I’ve used brownie mixes up to six months past their expiration date with no issues other than some lost flavor.

How long does Brownie Mix last (shelf life)

Brownie mix has a long shelf life when stored in its original bag or airtight container in a cool, dark place.

The brownie mix will keep for at least 4 months past the sell-by date, with some mixes having a shelf life of up to a year or more past the sell-by date.

The key to using an old box of brownie mix is ​​to simply prepare it and check that it rises and provides the flavor you want. You almost never have to worry that it’s not safe to eat when stored properly.

The brownie mix has a shelf life of 4 months to 1 year past the best before date.

What happens to the old brownie mix?

Most brownie mixes contain baking soda (sodium bicarbonate) or baking soda, which helps your brownies rise.

Baking soda and baking soda can lose their buoyancy ability over time, allowing old brownie mix to come out flat.

If your brownie mix is ​​quite old, you can add some baking soda or baking soda to help rise.

Note: All brownie mixes vary slightly in how much baking powder they use. For that reason, I’m going to find a recipe that’s similar in yield to my mix and add 3/4 of the baking powder called for to my brownie mix.

Older brownie mixes can also lose their flavor. You can judge this after baking your brownies.

You can enhance the flavor of your brownies by frosting them. You can use a pre-made frosting or make your own. I love this easy chocolate ganache recipe for frosting brownies.

Important: If your brownie mix was stored improperly or was of poor quality, chances are they just won’t turn out as well. If that happens, just go ahead and make another brownie mix.

How to store brownie mix in boxes

Brownie mix should always be stored in a cool, dark place. The pantry or a closet is the best choice to maximize shelf life.

Always keep your brownie mix away from direct sunlight or extreme heat. Moisture will degrade your brownie mix, so always store it in its sealed original container whenever possible.

If your brownie mix bag is unsealed, transfer your powder to an airtight container and store in a cupboard or pantry. Write the best before date on it so you don’t forget when you kept it.

Sometimes you might want to do half a batch. If so, place your leftover brownie mix in a freezer bag and seal. Write the date on it and keep it in a cool, dark place.

Frequently asked questions about expired brownie mixes

How long past the expiration date can you use the brownie mix?

Brownie mix can be used up to 1 year after the best before date. Flavor and leavening agents can degrade after 3 or 4 months. But your brownie mix has a long shelf life and is safe to eat many months after the best by date.

What Happens When You Use Expired Brownie Mixture?

Old brownie mix can lose its flavor and come out flat. This is because the ingredients lose their potency over time. But your brownie mix is ​​safe to eat months past the best before date.

How do you bake old brownie mix?

Baking instructions will vary depending on the brand and type of brownie being made. Follow the directions on the back of your brownie mix box. You may need to add some baking soda or baking soda if it’s more than four months past its sell-by date to ensure it rises properly.

Some popular brands that you may use are as follows. You can check their websites for baking instructions if you lost your brownie mix box.

So your brownies came out undercooked. Well, don’t get so defensive now! We know it wasn’t you. It was the recipe, the oven, the timer. Anything but YOU. But whatever the case, you’re the one who has to fix it.

Don’t worry. These delicious treats are easy to prepare. You can put them back on their tray and in the oven, or just pop them in a microwavable container and nucleate them for a few rounds.

i am angie I am a self taught baker who has been baking for over 10 years. I love brownies and I love to bake them. In this article, I’m going to teach you how to salvage your undercooked brownies. It’s really easy, so don’t panic.

Let’s bake!

How do you know when brownies are done?

You can tell when brownies are done by looking at them. The top of your brownie should be dull and cracked. You can time your brownies according to the recipe.

You can also do the toothpick test by sticking a toothpick in the center of your brownies and looking for a streak of chocolate goo when it comes out. Alternatively, you can simply check the internal temperature of your brownies. If it reads between 165 and 210°F, it’s cooked.

I wrote more about this in another article, check it out for more details.

How to fix undercooked brownies

There are two easy ways to fix undercooked brownies — in the oven or in the microwave.

1. In the oven

To fix undercooked brownies in the oven, simply bake your brownies on the same tray they were baked on. If you find they’re too sticky after removing them from the pan, you can always transfer them to a regular baking sheet and heat a little more in the 350°F preheated oven.

How long you leave them in the oven depends on the condition of your brownies. If you know your brownies undercooked a few minutes, simply pop them in the oven for that time. If in doubt, bake in the preheated oven, checking every three to five minutes.

2. In the microwave

For the microwave method, you need microwave-safe dishes. While oven heat travels through the pan from the outside in, microwave travels from the inside out, which is the perfect way to store your undercooked brownies without overcooking the sides.

Place your brownies in a microwave-safe bowl or container, set your microwave to medium-high, and heat the brownies in 30-second intervals. Check after each time, being careful not to burn your brownies.

frequently asked Questions

Still wondering why your brownies are undercooked and how to fix them? Find your answers below.

Why are my brownies raw in the middle?

The heat usually reaches the edge of the pan much earlier than the center. Because of this, your brownies may be cooked on the sides but undercooked in the middle.

If you followed the recipe exactly but your brownies are still raw in the middle, you may have used a pan that is too small, causing the brownie to thicken. The thicker the brownie, the longer it will take to cook.

However, keep in mind that your brownies may still be slightly sticky in the center when they’re done.

Should brownies be sticky in the middle?

This really is your personal preference. In general, to make brownies chewy and dumpy, your brownies should be slightly undercooked and sticky in the middle. Cakey brownies, on the other hand, should no longer be sticky.

How do you make brownies less sticky?

To make your brownies less sticky, you can cook them a little longer as above. Or if your brownies are already cooked but still too gooey for your liking, just pop them in the fridge and chill. The low temperature will help the chocolate and butter set and make them less sticky.

Do brownies harden as they cool?

Brownies will harden as they cool. This is because the fat and chocolate used in brownies are liquid in consistency when heated, but solidify when cooled.

How Long Should I Let Brownies Cool?

Typically, you should cool your brownies for at least half an hour before slicing or digging them. Keep in mind that the time will vary depending on the size of your pan and the thickness of your brownies. A larger tray may take up to two hours to cool. As a rule of thumb, just touch it with clean fingers and make sure they’re completely cool before slicing them.

Final Thoughts

You see, brownies aren’t difficult to make, nor are they difficult to fix. If you find your brownies are undercooked, just give them a quick pop in the oven or microwave and you’ll have perfect brownies waiting to hit your tummy.

How do you make undercooked brownies? Have you had any brownie disasters? Share them with us in the comments below!

Often recipes call for beaten eggs or for you to beat the eggs before adding them to a batter.

Beating the eggs before adding them to the batter is very important. However, this step is often skipped because many people think it is a waste of time. You simply crack the eggs right into the batter and get to mixing.

However, I encourage you not to skip the egg beating step if a recipe calls for it. Many batters, such as pancakes and muffins, can be overmixed. And if they’re mixed too much, the end result won’t be as good.

If you add the eggs whole, you’ll need to mix the batter more to incorporate the eggs and break them up. But if you beat the eggs before adding them to the batter, it won’t take very long to mix them in and you’re less likely to over-beat the batter you’re making.

So, if a recipe calls for beaten eggs, I encourage you not to skip the beating step. It will really make a difference in the end result.

Baking 101: a series of guides and tips for baking at home. Little things explained.

If you don’t already know, baking can be tricky. The tricky thing is that when reading a recipe (and you absolutely should read a recipe before you head into the kitchen) it’s hard to know which steps are very important and which steps you can screw up a bit.

This is how most of my recipes start:

“Place a rack in the center or top third of the oven and preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.”

Yes…I’m bossy enough to tell you exactly where to place the grate in your own oven. Some nerves, isn’t it? Sooooo annoying. The Bossy has a function – to our wild baking success.

Let’s talk about stoves first. You see, there is a difference in heat power in different parts of the furnace heating box. Most ovens have two heat sources, one below and one above. Normally, when we turn on the oven to preheat, both heating elements activate to heat the oven. Once the oven has reached our desired temperature, the bottom heat source will occasionally turn on to maintain the oven’s temperature.

Hot air rises, so the top of the oven is actually constantly hotter, while the bottom of the oven heats up in bursts to maintain the overall temperature.

The bottom rack is great for crusty breads and pizzas…baked goods that you want to brown intensely on the bottom.

The top rack is great for things you want a crispy brown surface on…things like cakes and casseroles.

The center rack is the happy spot where air circulates, heat sources are evenly distributed, and the top and bottom don’t burn or brown too quickly. It’s the perfect spot for cakes, cookies, and brownies to linger and bake.

If you have a busy oven and are baking more than one pan at a time, be sure to rotate the baked goods between the racks. For example, if you’re baking two sheets of cookies at the same time, swap the bottom pan halfway through and the middle pan down halfway through baking. Same goes for cake layers, but be sure to set the cake before moving the cake around in the oven…it might collapse.

Here’s the thing, just because you start with a rack doesn’t mean you’re married to it! Agitating baked goods in the oven helps our baked goods bake evenly. Think about what you want from your baked goods and go for it.

For pies, you need a heat burst to flake the crust, time in the oven to set the filling, and some time on top of the oven to brown the crust. Because of this, we can start a pie on the bottom rack to brown the bottom crust, move it to the middle rack for most of the baking time, and finish the oven on the top rack to brown the crust. See? This is an even bake.

For pizzas, you want a crispy crust and a browned, bubbly top. Now that you know where the heat lives in the oven, start by baking pizza in a hot, hot oven on the bottom rack and once cooked, move it to the top rack to brown the cheese (maybe even kick the grill , if you feel it!).

With a little knowledge of the stove and knowing where the heat comes from and how it lives, the power is yours. Placement is key, but you’re not married to an oven rack.

When in doubt, stay in the middle and don’t be afraid to conform.

(For the purposes of this post, I’m talking about electric and gas ovens. We’ll be talking about convection ovens in a few weeks!)

Here is more knowledge in the Baking 101 series –

Baking 101: How to Frost a Cake

Baking 101: How to Brown Butter

Backen 101: My favorite vegan egg substitute

Baking 101: What’s in a Whisk?

Baking 101: How to crack and separate an egg

Sugary ingredients like caramel sauce and mini marshmallows should be added after your brownies come out of the oven. If you try tossing caramel or mixing mini marshmallows into the batter before baking, they will melt with the brownies and disappear.

Drizzle caramel sauce over your brownies after they’ve baked and cooled. For the marshmallow topping, evenly sprinkle a layer of marshmallows over baked brownies straight out of the oven. Return pan with brownies to oven and broil until marshmallows are lightly browned, 1 to 3 minutes. (Watch the oven constantly. The marshmallows will melt easily, but should hold their shape.) Remove the pan from the oven immediately. Let the brownies cool completely on a wire rack, about 2 hours.

Do you have too many brownies? This is the opposite of a problem.

Whether freshly baked or out of the box, everyone loves a good brownie. The combination of the brownies’ rich flavor, chewy edges, and fluffy texture makes for one of the most perfect desserts on the planet, and they’ll easily please a group.

But if you’ve been baking for a crowd, there may be leftovers. Read on to learn the best ways to store brownies at room temperature, in the fridge, or in the freezer.

How to store brownies

Store brownies at room temperature by wrapping them tightly in plastic wrap or foil, or placing them in an airtight container such as a lidded tray or Tupperware container. This will prevent your brownies from going stale and keep any potential contaminants out.

Brownies with perishable toppings or mix-ins like cream cheese should be refrigerated and stored in an airtight container.

A square white casserole dish filled with Brooke’s Best Bombshell Brownies, neatly cut into 12 servings with two pieces pulled out. Photo credit: Allrecipes Magazine

Do brownies need to be refrigerated?

Brownies don’t need to be refrigerated, but once they are, they’ll keep for a few more days. Unless your brownies contain perishable ingredients like fresh fruit or cream cheese frosting, they’re fine at room temperature as long as they’re stored in an airtight container.

Can you freeze brownies?

Individual Brownies: To freeze brownies, wrap tightly in plastic wrap and aluminum foil and place in an airtight container such as a container. B. a freezer bag with a zipper. Label the bag accordingly.

Slab Brownies: To freeze a fresh pan of brownies, you need to plan ahead and line your baking pan with parchment paper. Make sure to leave enough parchment paper so you can lift the brownies out after they’re done. Bake the brownies according to the instructions, remove from the oven and allow to cool completely. Lift the brownies over the parchment paper, then wrap tightly with plastic wrap and add a layer of foil. Store wrapped brownies in a ziplock airtight bag and label before placing in the freezer.

Thawing: To thaw frozen brownies, remove them from the freezer and let them thaw at room temperature on a plate or in an airtight container. You can also microwave frozen brownies in 15-second increments on low power.

How long do brownies keep?

Brownies will last 3 to 4 days in an airtight container at room temperature and up to a week in the fridge. Brownies will last up to 3 months in the freezer, but if left frozen for any length of time their flavor and quality will begin to deteriorate.

Stored in a cool, dark place, the unopened boxed brownie mix will keep for between 12 and 18 months.

Related:

I know, I know. Waiting for your brownies to cool can be the longest wait of your life. Float in the air in this rich chocolate flavor and stare at the thin, perfectly cracked film on your brownie teasing you with its warmth. I mean it’s basically asking for it.

Asking to be immediately cut and melt in your mouth, that is. But no! Resist temptation at all costs because the perfect brownie is one that has been chilled. You should let your brownies cool for at least 30 minutes before slicing them.

I’m Angie and I’m slightly obsessed with brownies. I started a home baking business last year and my brownies have always been customer favorites. I know exactly how it feels to want to cut brownies as soon as they come out of the oven, and I’ve learned through my mistakes to know exactly why I shouldn’t!

In this article, I share with you the art of chilling brownies. Why we have to, how long we should chill it and how to do it quickly.

I think I deserve pluses for that.

Why cool brownies?

A cruel act like this needs a good justification. Why do we have to wait for brownies to cool down?

The main reason for this is – to achieve a gooey and fiddly consistency, we as bakers are told never to cook a brownie all the way through. To be sure, we take them out when they’re still a little short, especially in the middle.

The residual heat from the brownie pan cooks the brownie a little more, so you don’t have to worry about your brownies being undercooked.

But since the inside of the brownie isn’t fully set yet, removing it from the pan and slicing it through will cause the brownie to fall apart and all that’s left is a gooey mess and chocolate all over it. To achieve the clean cuts you see on store-bought brownies, you need to let them cool.

Aside from the fact that chilled and firm brownies are easier to cut, many say brownies taste even better the next day because the chilling process helps them lock in all the flavors better.

How long to cool brownies?

How long is this waiting time? Expect at least 30 minutes and we’ll get started from there.

For a clean cut

You need to let your brownies cool for at least half an hour before removing them from the pan. The length of time may vary depending on the temperature in your location. Rule of thumb – wait until your brownie is completely cool to the touch before slicing it.

To get a perfectly clean edge, use a knife warmed in hot water and wipe off any residue on the knife before and after each cut.

For frosting

If you plan to top your brownies with a layer of frosting, make sure your brownies are completely cool, preferably in the fridge, before you start frosting.

This isn’t a strict rule if you plan to cover your brownie in ganache, but expect your ganache to take longer than usual to set.

If using buttercream icing, the heat of the brownie will cause your buttercream to melt or crack, which is why a chilled or fully chilled brownie is preferred.

How to quickly chill brownies?

If the 30+ minute wait is just too much for you, try this method to cool it down faster.

To do this, you’ll need aluminum foil, ice, a bowl, tray, or sink large enough to fit on top of your brownie tray.

Wrap the entire tray of brownies in foil. Double the layer for extra security. This is to prevent water from coming into contact with your brownies. We don’t want mushy brownies. Fill your bowl, tray or sink with ice. Place your foil wrapped tray inside and cover the sides with ice as well. You can also use ice packs for this. Take out your tray after 20-30 minutes.

This method should greatly reduce the time it takes for your brownie to cool completely.

frequently asked Questions

Still have questions about chilling brownies? Here I answer them for you.

Will my brownies harden as they cool?

Your brownies will firm up as they cool, but not hard unless you’ve chilled them in the fridge or freezer.

The texture of your brownies should be at their best at room temperature – soft, firm and melt-in-your-mouth. However, the low temperature in the fridge will solidify the butter and chocolate in your brownie and harden it.

Can you let brownies cool overnight?

You can let your brownies cool overnight. In fact, your brownies will taste even better the next day when all the flavors are locked in. Just make sure you wrap them tightly or put them in airtight containers before storing them in the fridge, as the fridge tends to dry out food.

Do you let brownies cool in the pan?

I highly recommend that you cool your brownies in the pan for the first 30 minutes. Any attempt to remove or cut into the pan before it has cooled could result in your brownie falling apart.

Can I put brownies in the freezer?

Yes you can. In fact, freezing brownies is the best way to keep them fresh for a long time. You can freeze brownies for up to 3 months. Just make sure you wrap them airtight in a freezer-safe bag and let them cool completely before putting them in the freezer.

Final Thoughts

Like I said, slicing into freshly baked brownies is a crime you’ll regret (or will you?)

I hope all of this newfound knowledge of chilling brownies has helped you gather enough strength and determination to resist the temptation to eat your brownies as soon as they’re done. Patience is always the key.

Guilty of cutting and eating your brownies right away? Do you think it’s worth it? Let us know what you think in the comments below!